Skip to main content

It is not always possible to mend fences – Reinstatement is not always a practicable option where there is a breakdown in employment relations

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) upheld claims of constructive dismissal and disability discrimination against Whyte & Mackay Limited (W&ML) in the case of Mr. Duployen , a former forklift truck and warehouse operator, following his termination.   

W&ML had appealed the ET's decision on several grounds, seeking reinstatement or re-engagement, a higher award for injury to feelings, and any interest due on the awards. However, reinstatement proved impracticable due to the breakdown in relations and, while theoretically possible, it was not reasonable given the circumstances. Although the issue of re-engagement, while not addressed by the ET, is a required step per Sections 113 and 116 of the Employment Rights Act (ERA) 1996, tribunals are not compelled to order either a reinstatement or re-engagement, even though they have the discretion to do so.

The tribunals found that the appellant suffered embarrassment, humiliation and distress as a consequence of the discriminatory treatment by the respondent with a detrimental impact on his mental health.  

This is a cautionary tale for employers and HR departments alike, and the letter of the law should be followed diligently in terms of the Employment Rights Act (ERA) 1996, the ECHR, and the Human Rights Act (HRA) 1998 to avoid claims of discrimination or constructive dismissal, especially given that not all handicaps or disabilities are self-evident.

Beware false business rates warnings

The 2023 Revaluation updates business property rateable values, based on April 2021 valuations. While challenges are open until March 2026, beware of false claims about earlier deadlines and unscrupulous agents pushing for quick decisions or upfront payments.

The Valuation Office Agency (VOA) periodically reassesses the rateable values of business properties through a process known as Revaluation. This is done to update the rateable values in line with changes in the property market. The most recent revaluation took effect on 1 April 2023, with rateable values now based on the valuation date of 1 April 2021.

The VOA is aware of false claims that are being made about upcoming deadlines to appeal the 2023 rating lists. These are not true. You should be wary of anyone making these claims.

You are generally able to challenge your property valuation on the 2023 list at any time until March 2026. Any claims of an earlier deadline are false.

You should be cautious of any agent who:

  • tries to pressure you to decide a course of action or sign a contract;
  • makes claims about ‘unclaimed credits’ or similar;
  • says they are acting on behalf of the VOA; or that
  • demands large sums of money up front.

The VOA reiterates that, although the majority of agents are trustworthy and offer excellent service, there is a small minority that operate in bad faith.

Designating a property as your main residence

Owning more than one property? You can claim Capital Gains Tax (CGT) relief on just one at a time. By formally electing your main residence within two years of property changes, you can optimise your CGT exemption and make the most of key tax benefits.

Taxpayers who own more than one property should be aware of a number of important considerations. An individual, married couple, or civil partnership can only claim Capital Gains Tax (CGT) relief on one property at a time. However, it is possible to designate which property will benefit from the CGT exemption at the time of sale by making a formal election.

To nominate a property as the main residence, a letter must be sent to HMRC specifying the full address of the property being nominated. This nomination must be signed by all owners of the property and the election must be made within two years of any change in the combination of properties owned. Additionally, the property must have been occupied as the main or only residence at some point in the past.

There are specific rules governing overseas properties and for non-UK residents. It is important to carefully consider the timing and frequency of making such elections. Notably, if a property has been used as a private residence at any time, the final nine months of ownership are disregarded for CGT purposes even if the individual was not residing in the property when it was sold.

How donations to charity can provide tax relief

Gift Aid transforms charitable donations by allowing charities and CASCs to claim 25p extra for every £1 given—at no additional cost to you. Higher and additional rate taxpayers can also claim valuable tax relief, making giving even more rewarding.

Higher and additional rate taxpayers can claim tax relief on the difference between the basic rate of tax and their highest rate. This can be done through their self-assessment tax return or by requesting HMRC to adjust their tax code.

Example: 

If a taxpayer donates £1,000 to charity, the total value of the donation to the charity is £1,250. The taxpayer can claim additional tax relief based on their tax rate:

  • £250 if they pay tax at 40% (£1,250 × 20%)
  • £312.50 if they pay tax at 45% (£1,250 × 25%)

It is important to ensure that the taxpayer has paid enough tax in the relevant year. Donations will qualify for tax relief as long as the total claimed does not exceed four times the amount of tax paid in that year. If more tax relief is claimed than entitled, the taxpayer must notify the charity and repay the excess to HMRC.

Additionally, taxpayers can make donations directly from their wages through a payroll giving scheme if their employer operates one approved by HMRC. This allows donations to be made tax-free from salary or pension payments.

Rolling over capital gains

Business Asset Rollover Relief allows you to defer Capital Gains Tax (CGT) when reinvesting proceeds from selling business assets. By rolling gains into the cost of new assets, tax is postponed until the new asset is sold. Learn how this relief can optimise your business investments.

Rolling over capital gains is a useful way to defer CGT when you sell or dispose of business assets.

Essentially, if you use the proceeds from selling an old asset to buy a new one, the gain is "rolled over" into the cost of the new asset. This means you do not have to pay CGT on the gain immediately; instead, the tax is deferred until you sell the new asset. This relief is known as Business Asset Rollover Relief. The amount of the gain is effectively rolled over into the cost of the new asset and any CGT liability is deferred until the new asset is sold.

If you do not use all the proceeds from the sale to buy a new asset, you can still make a partial rollover claim. Additionally, you can apply for provisional rollover relief if you plan to buy new assets but have not yet done so.

Rollover relief also applies if you use the sale proceeds to improve assets you already own.

The total amount of relief depends on how much you reinvest in new assets. There are a few conditions to keep in mind.

  • the new asset must be purchased within 3 years of selling the old one (or up to a year before), though HMRC can sometimes extend this period;
  • both the old and new assets must be used for your business, and your business needs to be trading when you sell the old asset and buy the new one; and
  • claims for relief must be made within 4 years of the end of the tax year when the new asset was bought (or the old one was sold, if that happened later).